When to Fire Your CPA
How to Spot Incompetence—and Unlock $50k+/Year in Hidden Tax Savings by 2025
Fiends!
Let’s cut through the BS: 40% of small businesses overpay taxes by $12,000+ annually (IRS, 2024). If your CPA isn’t actively slashing that overpayment, you’re leaving money on the table. The bottom line? You need a tax professional gunning for your profit—especially given the complex 2025 tax landscape ahead.
Ready to dive deeper? Our Premium Membership gives you insider access to advanced strategies and personalized guidance—precisely what you need to tackle 2025’s tax hurdles head-on.
You’ll have the blueprint for maximizing every legal loophole.
🔍 Why “Good Enough” Isn’t Enough in 2025
New regulations like the SECURE Act 2.0, R&D amortization clawbacks, and state tax migration wars make tax planning a high-stakes game. But here’s the kicker: 68% of CPAs still rely on outdated, 2017-style strategies (AICPA 2024 Survey).
Red flag #1: They’re silent on these 2025 plays:
State residency arbitrage: With 9 states cutting income taxes since 2022, you can stack entity structures (like a “nomad LLC”) to dodge hefty state levies.
Energy credit stacking: For solar and wind projects, leverage the 30% IRA Section 48E credit and bonus depreciation in tandem.
PTE (Pass-Through Entity) elections: 36 states now allow S-corps/LLCs to bypass the $10k SALT cap—essential if you’re in a high-tax state.
💸 3 Signs Your CPA is Costing You 6 Figures
They dismiss credits without real due diligence
Fact: 92% of CPAs never revisit R&D credit eligibility after an initial “no.”
Example: A SaaS founder with $200k in dev expenses could net $14k/year via the Alternative Simplified Credit—even while unprofitable.
They offer zero proactive entity structuring
Case study: A Florida e-commerce business grossing $800k/year paid $142k in taxes as an S-corp. By migrating to a Series LLC with a Wyoming holding company and Nevada operating entity, they saved over $50k—and retained liability protection.
They’re silent on retirement mega-backdoors
SECURE Act 2.0 raised after-tax contributions to $69k/year (up from $58k) for solo 401(k)s. If your CPA isn’t pairing that with a Cash Balance Plan, you could miss out on six-figure deferrals.
📊 Outdated vs. Proactive CPA: A 2025 Strategy Snapshot
🛠️ The 5-Minute CPA Audit (Action Plan)
Request a “missed opportunity” analysis
“Show me every credit/deduction I didn’t take in 2023—and why.”
Test their 2025 IQ
Ask: “How would you use California’s new PTE elective tax to offset my federal liability?”
Look for specifics on QBI deductions and AMT cross-credits in their answer.
Do the math
Your CPA’s fee should be under 20% of your annual tax savings. If you’re paying $5k and only saving $10k, it’s time to upgrade.
🚨 When to Fire Your CPA: The Checklist
A CPA who can’t confidently say “yes” to all of these is likely costing you big:
“Have you filed a Form 3115 to change my accounting methods?” (e.g., shifting cash-to-accrual)
“Are we harvesting $3k in capital losses annually against ordinary income?”
“Are we using SEC 105H MERPs to structure owner health premiums?” (saves ~$8k/year per partner)
The Bottom Line
A genuinely great CPA doesn’t just save you money—they make you hate the IRS less. In 2025, the gap between a $40k tax bill and a $140k tax bill comes from aggressive legal interpretations, not plain-vanilla compliance.
If your CPA’s boldest suggestion is “Have you thought about a SEP IRA?”—it’s time to cut ties. Look for someone skilled with charitable remainder trusts, domestic and international sales corporations, and other advanced maneuvers that can save you thousands.
Pro Tip: Enrolled Agents (EAs) are IRS-licensed, often 30% cheaper than CPAs, and frequently more audit-savvy. Consider one if you’re ready to upgrade.
Don’t settle for “average” when your business deserves exceptional. Click below to subscribe and start securing the tax savings you deserve. Your future self (and bank account) will thank you.